Debunking the “Cooling Inflation” Argument for Low Social Security COLAs

In last year’s Social Security Administration’s press release covering the 2025 COLA announcement, then-Commissioner Martin O’Malley made this comment:

“Social Security benefits and SSI payments will increase in 2025, helping tens of millions of people keep up with expenses even as inflation has started to cool.”

An increase AND cooling inflation. It’s a win-win, right? No, it’s not!

Cooling inflation doesn’t mean lower prices. It merely means prices are raising at a slower pace. They haven’t gone back down, though the COLA has gone down for the fourth consecutive year. And with 2026 COLA predictions now emerging, seniors should be conscious of the fact that cooling inflation doesn’t mean more affordable prices.

Don’t buy that a low COLA is justified based on any formal economic analysis. The best way to analyze this topic is to consider the financial struggles seniors are facing. And remember, we paid into Social Security, and therefore we deserve to be paid back in full.